Skip to main

Best Pizza in Lenox Hill, Manhattan, NY

Where Simple Ingredients Create Moments That Last Every Day

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Sicilian Pizza

Large 16". Mozzarella and tomato sauce

Add Item

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Spicy buffalo chicken and mozzarella

Add Item

Cheese Pizza

Add Item

Vodka Pizza

Regular

Add Item

Hawaiian Pizza

Fresh ham, pineapple, mozzarella, and tomato sauce

Add Item

Pepperoni Pizza

Add Item

Bruschetta

Add Item

Penne Alla Vodka

Penne with our homemade vodka sauce

Add Item

Spaghetti with Meatballs

With three pieces of meatballs

Add Item

Warm Greetings From Uncle Vinny’s

Warm Greetings From Uncle Vinny’s
Step into Uncle Vinny’s Pizza where warm smiles greet every guest. Our cozy dining room and outdoor seating invite locals, tourists, families, and couples to enjoy fresh, locally sourced ingredients each day. Every pie is crafted daily using simple recipes and ingredients from nearby farms. Full service dining blends Italian pizza traditions with a casual vibe. Delivery, pickup, and dine-in options make enjoying our pizzas easy.

Fresh, Local Ingredients Daily

Fresh, Local Ingredients Daily
Uncle Vinny’s Pizza takes pride in using ingredients sourced from nearby farms and producers. Every morning, our dough is hand-stretched and topped with garden-fresh vegetables, house-made sauces, and locally cured meats. Seasonal produce finds its way onto pizzas for fresh variety. This commitment ensures a bright, natural taste in each bite. From classic Margherita to bold Pesto pizza, you’ll taste the care behind every pie. It’s a simple promise of freshness from our kitchen to your plate.
Build Your Feast

More than Just Pizzas

More than Just Pizzas
More than just pizza — enjoy fresh salads, flavorful pasta, crispy wings, garlic knots, calzone and more. Every dish is made with quality ingredients and crafted to satisfy every craving.
Order Online
Order With Ease

Order With Ease

Online ordering at Uncle Vinny’s Pizza is simple and quick on our website. The menu is easy to browse by dish type or favorites list. Choose delivery or pickup and customize your choices with just a few clicks. Visit our website to order your favorite pizza, pasta, salad, wings, and more for delivery or pickup today.
Order Online

Snapshots of Fresh Creations and Welcoming Moments

Cozy Dining & Outdoor Seats

Cozy Dining & Outdoor Seats
At Uncle Vinny’s Pizza, every visit feels welcoming. Our full service dining room offers cozy booths and open tables perfect for families or couples sharing a meal. Food enthusiasts can watch dough stretch at our open kitchen bar. Outside, shaded tables invite locals and tourists alike to savor pizza in the fresh air. The casual vibe ensures each guest feels at home from first slice to last. Soft evening lighting sets a relaxed mood ideal for date nights or group gatherings.

Find Us On First Avenue

Visit Uncle Vinny’s Pizza at 1140 1st Avenue, Unit 2, New York, NY 10065 in the Upper East Side. We’re open Sunday from 10 am to 10 pm, Monday through Wednesday until midnight, Thursday until 2 am, and Friday and Saturday until 4 am. Street parking and a nearby subway station make getting here easy. Our Unit 2 entrance sits just off the main street, leading into a bright, inviting dining area. Look for the neon pizza sign above the door. Stop by to grab a slice hot from our ovens.

What our guests are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

The guy behind the counter hooked it up! We got 4 slices for the price of 3 at around midnight. We are vegetarian and they had veggie slices ready to go. Happy I found this place.

AJ B.

AJ B.

I was craving pizza and buffalo wings. I made the right choice coming here. I don't get pizza too often, but their grandma's pizza was by far the best slice I've had in a while. Store was a bit hot inside but worth the visit.

Natalie M.

Natalie M.

Every time I come to the restaurant, I never have any problems. The food is amazing – the sauce, the cheese, everything is fresh. the best place to eat is Uncle Vinnie‘s pizza.

Eric B.

Eric B.

Featuring

Delivery

Takeout

Dine In

Gluten-Free Options

Vegan Options

Uncle Vinny’s Pizza Rewards

Uncle Vinny’s Pizza Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online, and redeem your points for free food!

Frequently asked questions

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

We are located in New York, NY at 1140 1st Ave

Our location